Weed herbicide resistance and its management

2.1K

Introduction to herbicide resistance

The presence of weeds on farmland can result in significant loss of crop yields because weeds compete with field crops for essential resources. Tillage, manual weeding, crop diversification and crop rotation were the prior means of managing weeds before herbicides became commercially available. However, over the years it has become more and more common in many countries to use herbicides for weed control.

Farmers are able to avoid crop yield loss caused by unwanted weeds by using herbicides. Weed control with herbicides is extremely effective and economical, but if they are applied excessively, the development of herbicide resistance in weed plants will render the herbicides ineffective. 

The most prominent disadvantage of these herbicides is the development of resistance in the targeted weeds. 

Weed biotypes that are resistant to different herbicides have grown rapidly. There are currently 383 types of biotypes belonging to 208 weed species in 570,000 fields worldwide (122 dicots and 86 monocots). 

What is herbicide resistance ?

A weed plant’s ability to survive and reproduce even after exposure to a herbicide is known as herbicide resistance of weed plant. This quality is acquired by the weed when it is exposed to the same herbicide repeatedly. The weed develops “immunity” to the amount of dose that would normally kill it. Subsequently, the farmer increases to dose in an attempt to kill the weed and the vicious cycle continues.

Herbicide resistance in weeds develops in two ways. First, the weed evolves and alters the weed plant site which is affected by the herbicide. Second, the weed plant changes the processes in its growth cycle which is targeted by the herbicide to be effective.  

How do plants become resistant to herbicides?

Following are the ways with which plants become resistant to herbicides

• Natural dispersal : The wind and water are also capable of spreading weed seeds. Likewise, pollen can be dispersed over great distances, although only a small percentage remains viable at distances beyond 10m. Furthermore, weed seeds can be transported long distances by floodwaters.  
• Pre-existing resistance : Occasionally, some plants in the weed colonies contain a rare gene mutation that enables them to survive an application of a herbicide that would normally kill their species. Weed plants may undergo genetic variation that alters their ability to absorb and translocate the herbicide. Furthermore, physiological changes may affect a plant’s ability to metabolize herbicides or allow herbicides to travel to a non-lethal location within the plant.
• Importation of resistance : This is a very rare form of herbicide resistance which occurs in weeds when the weed contaminates in crop seed or fodder or in agriculture machinery to be used before seed plantation.

Example of herbicide resistance

According to Malik and Singh, 1995; Balyan and Malik, 2000; Yadav and Malik, 2005 : Over the last several decades, the weed flora in wheat farmlands has changed dramatically. As irrigated areas expanded, Carthamus oxycantha has almost disappeared from wheat production, where it was a major weed in 1960. P. minor and Avena ludoviciana have replaced several broadleaf weeds since the mid-1960s due to the introduction of high-yield dwarf wheat varieties, as well as increased fertilizer use and guaranteed irrigation.

In rice-wheat cropping systems, P. minor became the dominant weed.

In other cropping systems, A. ludoviciana became the dominant weed on irrigated, well-drained, lighter textured soils. 

Manual weed removal is difficult on wheat because of its close row spacing and its morphological resemblance to grass weeds.

In Northwest India, including Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Delhi, P. minor is still inflicting large yield losses in wheat crop, especially in rice-wheat growing systems. 

Weeds such as P. minor are also posing major threats to wheat production in neighbouring states, such as Uttaranchal, Madhya Pradesh and parts of Bihar and Himachal Pradesh.

Phalaris minor is reported to be developing resistance to herbicides such as Isoproturon, Sulfosulfuron, Clodinafop, Fenoxaprop, Pinoxaden and Tralkoxydim.

Evolution of Herbicide Resistance

Herbicide resistance can be explained by two theories: either the gene pool theory or the selection theory.

• Gene pool theory : Herbicides are regarded as mutagens because they cause mutating plants due to herbicide treatment, which affects the genetic makeup of the plant. However, this theory is not well supported by research.
• Selection theory : This is a more widely accepted theory. It is natural for some plants in weed populations to be resistant to a particular herbicide. The efficacy of a herbicide determines the selection pressure

Herbicide Resistance Mechanism

Target site mechanism

• Site of action overproduction : Dilution of the herbicide results from this. The number of site of action in the weed plant increases considerably which in turn reduces the quantity of required herbicide in the site of action.
  Example : There has been evidence that some glyphosate-resistant Palmeramaranth plants show enhanced amounts of herbicide-susceptible EPSPS target-site proteins. Until now, no case of this mechanism has been found for another plant species.
• Altered site of action : The weed changes the characteristics of the site of action in a manner which doesnt allow the herbicide to act in the way it is intended to.
  Example : Sulfonylurea herbicides resistant Lactuca sativa biotypes.  ALS enzyme of site of action does not bind with the herbicide anymore.

Non target site mechanism/exclusionary:

Weeds that prevent the herbicide molecule from reaching the site where it causes a toxic response in plants. The herbicide is excluded from the site of action in many ways through exclusionary resistance mechanisms.

• Differential herbicide uptake : Because of morphological characteristics such as overproduction of waxes, reduced leaf area, etc., herbicide resistant biotypes do not readily absorb herbicides.
  
• Differential translocation : These resistant biotypes have different modifications that reduce the apoplastic (cell wall, xylem) and symplastic (plasma lemma, phloem) transport of herbicide.
  
• Compartmentation : Herbicide is separated into many sections of the weed plant before it reaches the site of action on the weed plant or the herbicide is attached to the cell walls of the site where it proves to be ineffective.
  
• Metabolic detoxification : Herbicide undergoes faster detoxification before it reaches its target site in the weed plant. There are four major categories of biochemical detoxification: oxidation, reduction, hydrolysis, and conjugation. Resistance to herbicides is associated with the activation of three enzymes : 
  (i) Aryl-aylamidase that detoxifies propanil
  (ii) Glutathione-s-transferase that detoxifies atrazine
  (iii) A number of grasses and weeds are resistant to inhibitors of ACCase, ALS, and PSII due to cytochrome P450 monoxygenase

Herbicide Resistance Management

Herbicide resistance developing in weed can be controlled and managed by 2 ways : Proactive management practices and Reactive management practices

Proactive management practices to reduce herbicide resistance

I. Cultural practices

• Crop rotation
  
  Growing the same crop usually demands application of the same herbicide in the same ratio. This is a huge enabler for weeds to develop herbicide resistance.
  
  Farmers can reduce the chances of weeds developing resistance if crop are changed every year or every season. This will raise the need for use of different herbicides and as a result will prevent the weed to adapt to the herbicide.
  
  This also hampers the growth season of the weed plant.
  
  Some crops are more competitive then other crops. This high competing crop will limit the weed seed production.
  
  
• Appropriate sowing time
  
  Crops that are sown early are more competitive against weeds and grow faster. 
  
  During the last week of November through December, as well as in the beginning of January, Phaloris minor (P. minor) germinates more profusely under rice-wheat cropping systems. Hence, early seed sowing practice is recommended specially for rice-wheat farming system. As planting wheat between the last week of October and the second week of November helps the crop have a better survival chance when competing with P. minor.
  
  Zero tillage makes the early sowing of wheat easy.
  
  
• Closer crop planting spacing and higher seed rate
  
  Crops planted with less spacing will help in reducing the weed population because of unavailability of surface area for weed to grow.
  
  

II. Mechanical practice

Employing various mechanical practices such as manual rouging, preplant tillage and itterrow farming can also help in alleviating the problem of herbicide resistant weed.

Use of plastic mulches can also help in preventing the growth of weeds and eventual growth of herbicide resistant weed variety.

Weeds and crop plants are both provided with access to nutrients when fertilizers are broadcast. Trying to manually drill the fertilizer in the seed furrows will provide the nutrients only to the plant and not the weed plants

III. Herbicide rotation and herbicide mixing

Herbicide mixtures techniques work on the principle that if a weed possesses genes for resistance to one group of herbicides, another group of herbicides will kill it. 

Using a variety of herbicides and not depending on use of just one herbicide is a good practice to prevent weed plants from developing resistance. Herbicide rotation should be practiced whenever possible.

Use the herbicide in the recommend dose range only and prefer a herbicide with low residual life span.

Reactive management practices to reduce herbicide resistance

• Mechanical options
  
  Proper sanitation of agricultural equipment and controlling the weed escapes.
  
  Whenever feasible, postharvest grazing by farm animals.
  
  Physical scouting of the field.
  
  Stubble burning
  
• Herbicide options
  
  Select a herbicide that acts differently from the one you currently use to prevent post-emergence herbicide resistance.
  
  The maximum labelled rate of postemergence foliar herbicide should be applied if low level herbicide resistance is identified and no alternative is available.

FAQ

How do you manage herbicide resistance?

Answer : Plant populations almost always exhibit genetic variation. As long as there are genetic variations, selection will likely lead to resistance if it is intensified and prolonged for enough time i.e. if the weed is exposed to the same pesticide for a long time. It is impossible to avoid herbicide resistance because it occurs at random. A key component of management strategies is the rotational use of herbicides and mixtures of herbicides. It would be helpful to manage weeds using a holistic approach to weed management such as integrated weed management.

Why is herbicide resistance a problem?

Answer : Weed herbicide resistance is a big problem in farming as weeds consume a significant proportion of the nutrients being supplied to the crop resulting in low yield of the crop. As the population of herbicide resistance weed increases in the farm, not only sustaining a good crop yield becomes difficult but also the farmer loses money spent on ineffective herbicide, spends more money in labour and reactive weed removal measures.

What is the difference between herbicide resistance and herbicide tolerance?

Answer : Herbicide resistance is the “acquired ability” of the weed plant which it develops after exposure to a specific herbicide for a long period of time.
On the other hand, Herbicide tolerance is the “inherent ability” of the weed to grow and reproduce even after being treated by a herbicide.